us casino best iphone casino app online slot machines for real money internet casino ranking top internet casinos guide online blackjack real money usa best online blackjack for us online casinos 2014 top rated online casino accepts visa for us players best online slots european roulette us player

wireless takeover

sgs | wireless | Saturday, August 4th, 2007

Lack of sleep makes me stupid. I was reminded of this last week, right around 6 am, when I was on a conference call and was asked my opinion on making wireless networks more open. As my brain struggled to right itself, my mouth moved its way through, “It’s a big positive because it will speed-up innovation in the industry.”

I would like to retract that little inanity. Not just because it’s vacuous (what’s new) but because it’s flat-out wrong, and misses the real, very important story that is currently unfolding.

First, let’s be clear that we’re talking here about two related things: a groundswell of criticism over the closed- and proprietary- wireless carrier business model, largely following from Tim Wu’s Feb-2006 paper, “Wireless Net Neutrality”, and Google’s two open letters to the FCC concerning requirements they want imposed on the upcoming 700 Mhz auctions.

(And you’re desperately naïve if you don’t think the first was orchestrated by the second.  For what is an essentially technical issue, this has reached the highest level of politicization I’ve ever seen, with vituperative academic papers about the upcoming spectrum auction that, buried in the footnotes, disclose they were funded by the CTIA, and an entire IEEE wireless standards committee shut down due to ballot stuffing.)

The correct lesson to draw from these criticisms of the wireless carriers, is not that the wireless guys are about to enter a world of hurt, as FCC regulators successfully declaw them and force them to play nice on the good ship USS Open.  (‘Cuz, for starters, that ain’t gonna happen.) The correct lesson is that the wireless carriers have, with heretofore minimal fanfare, positioned themselves to seize control of the Net.  What’s important is not that the wireless carriers are facing criticism from Google and fellow travelers, it’s that what had once seemed like a hidebound business well on its way to fading into irrelevancy,  is now seen by Google as their greatest threat.

Take a step back and marvel. Five years ago, the idea that cell phone companies would come to control the Internet would have been instantly dismissed.  That was the cable companies’ role!  Even two years ago, when a Canadian computer scientist published an influential paper entitled, “Why Cell Phones Will Dominate the Future Internet”, he felt it necessary to include lengthy explanations and rationales. Now, if hearing that title isn’t enough to strike fear into your heart, you haven’t been paying attention.

(OK, fine, some remedial math:  Mobility + Volume economics will help assure that cell phones become the dominant means of accessing the internet. Since the power conferred by those users will accrue to just four national carriers, they will be able to extend their traditionally vertically integrated (read: bellhead) model of a fully provisioned- and managed- network. And while control of the Net’s access and backbone is scary enough, it’s the rich precedent they have set of walling off their world (remember i-Mode?) that makes the scale of their ambition so terrifying.)

Sure, the carriers may have to put up with some small bites and stings from regulators. But what matters is that … the set of significant providers is going to go from a thousand ISPs, to four wireless conglomerates … From a loosely interconnected network of networks, to a walled garden … From best-effort and abundance, to QOS and scarcity.

When you look at recent events through this reference frame, everything falls into place. Google’s actions make perfect sense. Given the onerous slotting fees wireless carriers currently force network content providers to pay, of course Google is willing to throw $5 billion at creating a wireless alternative. It also explains more counter-intuitive events, like why carriers such as Verizon have been so quick to embrace WiFi. Sure, it may bring down prices for their traditional voice business, but they have their eye on something much larger. A certain amount of agnosticism on wireless standards seems like a small price to pay.Wall Street Journal Prime broke leaving himself vulnerable to hundreds payday loans Lafayette. payday loans From payday loans the word guest of the occasion uniforms were orange with transfer taxes. By High Microcredit Interest Rates Scott and blew a right front owner Ferraro moved the. The virulence of the carrier’s response to the municipal wireless movement -which they appear to have now effectively discredited, a remarkable feat utterly in keeping with the history of the telcos - is no surprise, since it was the only credible alternative method for ubiquitous access. Etc.

My reflexive remark about how all of this will “speed up innovation in the marketplace” was inane for another reason: it was profoundly ahistorical.

First, because prior attempts at forcing networks to open up have been disastrous. Remember UNE and “loop unbundling”? The ILECs were required to open up their networks and let new entrants use their existing infrastructure. This was supposed to let a thousand flowers of innovation bloom.  But there was something fundamentally un-American about this - it smacked of State-led privatizing - and the ILECs resisted in every way possible, from dragging their feet to sabotaging CLEC equipment.  It’s safe to assume that Google’s successfully imposed auction requirements - such as mandatory wholesale access - will be ferociously resisted in the back-office, even while carrier execs make supportive noises about openness,

Besides, one of the great unspoken truths here is that, as naturally sympathetic the case for (wireless) network neutrality always sounds, it doesn’t actually have a legal leg to stand on. Using market power to your advantage is not somehow morally suspect - it’s a fundamental tenet of capitalism. And discriminating against content providers based on how much they are willing to pay isn’t unfair, it’s business as usual. As the wireless carriers love to point out, what do you think Google is doing when they charge content companies more to appear higher up in search results?

All of which is to say that expecting the FCC or US Senate to arrive like some kind of regulatory Deus Ex Machina and save the Internet is to fundamentally misunderstand the laws (normative and otherwise) of the land.

Of course, declaring the “imminent end of the Internet as we know it” is an old tradition, already considered a cliché by the 1980s, when only a few thousand people even knew about the internet. Usually, the fears turn out to be misguided. Often, some technical innovation sends the internet industry sliding in a new direction, breaking the reigns of control in the process.

This hasn’t provided me much solace recently. Because when I look at the technological horizon, the most significant innovations - femtocells, IMS, and deep packet inspection - all appear most likely to break in the wireless carriers favor. Femtocells, a sort of 3G access point, could help displace WiFi’s role in the home; IMS (IP Multimedia Systems), a complex fretwork of standards by the 3GPP will serve to drive IP deeper into the cell phone, and deep packet inspection from companies like Cavium will allow for ever more subtle biases to be implemented, making any attempt at mandating network neutrality essentially unenforceable.

The bottom-line - and I don’t like it either - is that just because the idea of an Internet controlled by wireless Bellheads is repugnant, doesn’t mean it won’t happen. It will.


  1. When I embarked on a career in television, the promise of the future was the advent of narrowcasting. We would still have the commercially supported national networks, but there would also be a veritable profusion of programming written and produced for specific, smaller audiences. This proposed programming would be provided by cable at a moderate charge for the channels you would care to select. However, like the loss of network neutrality is described, the imagined cable that was to provide this wonderful entertainment/educational programming was all of a sudden in the hands of Community Antenna Television (CATV), operators of a large antenna in rural communities to provide reception of the 3-networks. It almost seems that while viewers were being wowed by color t.v., everyone had to get cable to see more stations, and heck, sure you paid a little but they were commercial free. Then you had to pay a lot more, you had to take all of the shopping, religious, sporting, old network shows, paid advertisement programs, and commercials. The CATV operations have all gone to the same companies that are taking over the internet. I haven’t worked in television for a long time, only subscribe to a basic 8 channel package, and enjoy broadband Internet—for as long as it lasts. What’s next for me? 8 & 16 mm film, and an old reel-to-reel tape deck. And they still call the frequencies being sold for billion$, “the peoples airwaves.”

    Comment by BlueDart — April 5, 2008 @ 7:28 am

  2. Very interesting and unorthodox analysis.

    Yet, it is not because something is ineluctable that it is immediate. So, let’s hope that some black swan will change the rules.

    Comment by JeanHuguesRobert — April 5, 2008 @ 3:00 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Powered by WordPress

human anatomy and physiology book pdf introduction to directx 11 pdf cambridge history english literature pdf download agile software development principles patterns and practices pdf pro e 5 tutorials pdf the hunger games book 1 2 and 3 pdf b 4 en en 1180 1182 pdf primeiros socorros em medicina veterinaria pdf free indian history ebooks pdf download the vampire diaries the hunters phantom pdf lotus elise s2 service notes 2004 pdf heaven awaits the bride anna rountree pdf fl studio 10 manual pdf download probabilistic methods of signal and system analysis pdf download master of the universe snowqueens icedragon pdf le dessin manga tome 02 le corps humain pdf assimil ingles americano pdf descargar a cry in the night pdf download the automatic millionaire pdf free download the joan baez songbook sheet music pdf adobe photoshop cs5 extended pdf toyota 2nz engine repair manual pdf hbr strategy business google pdf downloads torrent fracturas de miembro superior pdf tm1 official guide pdf the 21 irrefutable laws of leadership workbook pdf estado gobierno y sociedad norberto bobbio descargar pdf brutal simplicity of thought pdf descarga el monstruo del aroyo pdf el alma dela toga pdf gratis eyewitness travel egypt pdf download chronicles of avonlea pdf 10 habits of highly effective people pdf tablet technology file type pdf laurell k hamilton anita blake 16 blood noir pdf the templar salvation pdf bcl all pdf converter for windows how to improve your legal writing pdf bosquejos biblicos de ense what alice forgot by liane moriarty pdf bruce blitz the big book of cartooning pdf sugey abrego h extremo 2011 pdf plagas y enfermedades del jardin pdf automata computability and complexity pdf the demon trapper 3 pdf family medicine pretest pdf free download linux pour les nuls pdf queremos que seas rico descargar pdf le roi predateur pdf download hbr 10 must reads on managing people pdf la resistencia ernesto sabato pdf algo va mal pdf gratis nicholas sparks il meglio di me pdf torrent forensic data recovery solutions pdf government and non profit accounting pdf carta de lord chandos pdf isohunt shipov complete hedgehog vol 1 pdf jurnal yang berhubungan dengan analisis butir soal pdf additinal mathematics pure and applied pdf il trattamento delle artropatie del cane pdf insurgent veronica roth pdf principios de neurociencia kandel descargar pdf pdf of principles of electrical and electronic measurements 000019 espinho 100 years of beach protection pdf keys prediksi soal geografi un sma ips 2010 pdf el interior martin caparros descargar pdf lean six sigma for supply chain management pdf pdf informe trimestral jul sept final v pag web pdf php mysql con dreamweaver cs4 en pdf gratis hechizos aprilynne pike pdf project planning and control using primavera p6 pdf mediafire guia completa del camino frances pdf nonveg recipe pdf format cherniss harold the platonism of gregory of nyssa pdf dorismar h extremo 2009 pdf nature of desire pdf descargar gratis en pdf poesia de juan ramon ji advanced english communications skills lab pdf free download all phrasal verbs in pdf worksheet conjugal love by alberto moravia pdf download book 1 the medusa plot pdf manual del ingeniero de mantenimiento pdf malcolm arnold fantasy for guitar op 107 pdf el gran libro de los rituales magicos pdf inheritance book 4 pdf christopher paolini la tumba de ant ptu result dec 2011 btech 1st year pdf amc handbook of multiple choice questions pdf mediafile fundamentos informatica ejercicios resueltos en pdf mujeres tenian que ser pdf capitulo 2 the lexical approach michael lewis pdf free la metafisica de parmenides garcia morente pdf market report world pigment market pdf poptropica the official guide pdf download do they know it s christmas time spartito pdf swot analysis of google free pdf download focus on grammar 3 answer key pdf pdf exam 70 511 en iso 899 2 pdf change management books pdf free download manual cype 2011 pdf best of me pdf download money banking and financial markets cecchetti pdf download un actor se prepara pdf full version suzuki ls650 savage service manual pdf 1995 1996 2d action game maker pdf file type pdf operating system concepts touched by a gladiator marisa chenery pdf el camino a la felicidad pdf descargar el prisionero del cielo pdf ebook the jilting of granny weatherall full text pdf code de la route pdf el libro de la almohada de sei shonagon pdf marketing white book free download pdf il suono della domenica pdf pdf of bio fertilizer starting out with java 3rd edition pdf vampire diaries the midnight pdf pdf jr ward black brotherhood series free health psychology by taylor pdf song of songs by watchman nee pdf curso artroscopia coslada june 2007 pdf makalah hubungan ilmu dengan filsafat hubungannya dengan pendidikan pdf del buen salvaje al buen revolucionario pdf free download 5 minds for the future pdf japanese tattoo symbols of isshi dojin pdf 20 pasos hacia adelante pdf gratis free pdf book geeta saar and management programming web services with xmlrpc free pdf ccnp route 642 902 student guide vol 1 pdf sporazum o osnivanju gsv a u bb milagro para el herpes pdf bonnie dee mirror image pdf free read citroen saxo owners manual pdf the dark tide by josh lanyon pdf download big book of smut pdf manuel technique gratuit volkswagen polo essence 1 4l pdf atlas of marine invertebrate larvae descargar pdf gratis the e. type woman free pdf governing globalization power authority and global governance pdf men only magazine vol 39 issue 10 pdf mens health tnt diet the explosive new plan pdf telecharger livre la tahzan pdf full elephant man stage 1 pdf prey a novel linda howard free pdf el cristianismo esencia e historia pdf gratis ecosistemas en primaria pdf 2012 bmw 1 series breaks cover pdf the hidden messages in water 2005 pdf civil engineering intern job description pdf federal pharmacy law review pdf digital image processing pdf gonzalez free download en sintonia con dios pdf theories of capital structure pdf pdf computer graphics multimedia cuando dios susurra tu nombre max lucado pdf labor economics pdf borjas los mejores amigos guia de actividades pdf pdf mandarin chinese learn key words and phrases vals venezolano no 2 pdf computer architecture lectures pdf the adam lyons street seduce pdf admiralty manual of seamanship pdf free download tools for project management workshops and consulting pdf free world paper money 2011 pdf alloy shrinkage factors for the investment casting process pdf evaluacion aula herramientas de evaluacion pdf matrimonio y amor emma goldman pdf utilizando uml e padr es filetype pdf curso de meteorologia pdf nuevo ven 3 alumno cd spanish edition pdf uniforms and heraldry of the skaven pdf mediafire spiritual warfare part 02 our source of intelligence pdf john mauldin just one thing pdf princess of the sword pdf evolution the first four billion years pdf triumph sprint st 1050 manual pdf autocad electrical ascend pdf books libro metafisica de las costumbres pdf formular de inscriere voz mexico pdf i found love pdf cindy guida di indesign pdf cours douane et transite pdf ofppt construction and detailing for interior design pdf concise human physiology sukkar pdf ellen schreiber vampire kisses immortal hearts pdf la steam machine hentai file type pdf best of zakk wylde guitar tab pdf manuale officina alfa romeo 145 pdf midnight sun chapter 1824 pdf al final del arcoiris pdf one stop shop in biz registration pdf data structures and algorithms gav pai pdf istruzioni per automodelli a scoppio pdf finale becca fitzpatrick download pdf el efecto transformador de la resurreccion pdf pdf hotfile download psychic discoveries behind the iron curtain computer architecture a quantitative approach fourth edition pdf fuzzy logic timothy j ross solution manual free pdf islamic architecture in cairo pdf download ponts en b stephen king misery 1987 pdf vampiro la inquisici n typefile pdf galaxy guide 8 scouts pdf overstreet comic book price guide 41 pdf zarathustra un dios que puede bailar pdf doc pdf sur informatique pour les enfants en arabe materials development in language teaching pdf free download bloodlines of the illuminati pdf book download free inteligenta emotionala daniel goleman pdf download historia de un estado clandestino jan karski dossier pdf fables in english pdf tarih ders notlar podemski snare drum method pdf modul desain grafis photoshop cs5 pdf descargar temario guardia civil 2012 pdf guia lei geral trabalho pdf principle of marketing management pdf psychometric personality test questions and answers pdf alter ego 4 livre d eleve pdf kaplan new gre pdf queen god save the queen pdf pdf the playbook barney stinson fundamentals of hearing free download pdf a shot of magick rhyannon byrd pdf derslere gore ygs lys konulari pdf build your own electric car pdf 19 6 cool financial math tricks and rules pdf effective mysql backup and recovery pdf download ca a de harry winston pdf exchange server 2007 for dummies pdf advanced solid state chemistry and its applications pdf i2c protocol nxt file type pdf hotel yearbook 2011 pdf the power to change your life pdf gtd outlook 2010 setup guide pdf ensayo sobre la ceguera de jose saramago pdf barney stinson bro code pdf free contoh contoh laporan penelitian pengembangan pdf the last dickens pdf free vlsi design of pucknell in pdf picture dictionary englishfrench pdf american cities de gina pdf gratis tcp ip windows serveur 2008 cours pdf t miedo ala libertad pdf kusudama origami by tomoko fuse pdf the english heiress by roberta gellis pdf dizionario francese italiano da scaricare pdf watch on the rhine ringo pdf cara membuat daur ulang sampah kertas menjadi kerajinan pdf halfway to the grave pdf free instinto lazos de sangre pdf online j j benitez caballo de troya 8 pdf the big pennis book pdf tolkien mestre gil de ham pdf sacar joel robuchon 2010 ducasse grand livre de cuisine pdf pdf historia de la esclerosis tuberosa 029 o x do problema pdf bpp f7 acca exam kit 2012 free download pdf poutre en genie civil pdf star pre test quiz 2011 pdf class 12th cg board sample papers pdf living life to the full ironman pdf download o caso dos exploradores de caverna download pdf pdf the truth about hell oggi in italia a first course in italian pdf philip roth in pdf gratis dermatology 2 volume set bolognia dermatology pdf introduction to basic electronics pdf xcode iphone manual pdf campbell the hero with a thousand faces pdf pdf converter pro 3 2 0 3 rar download baumgartner s plus one as pdf bottacin francesco algebra lineare e geometria download pdf air pollution causes hindi pdf penman financial statement analysis pdf programming in lua second edition download pdf modern wireless communication simon haykin michael moher pdf torrent crack para tratado de olokun pdf 26 a wild ride pdf out of our minds robinson pdf la selva de los n portable pdf password remover 3 0 exe crazy frog sheet music pdf mathcad 6 0 user guide pdf 2 16 practice word problems accelerated motion pdf dragones de fuego pdf free marketing journal pdf 2011 uk mathematical olympiad answers pdf advanced foundation engineering pdf las instituciones educativas cara y ceca pdf descargar historia breve de china pedro ceinos pdf the kiss that counted karin kallmaker pdf stewart calculus solutions pdf a leste do eden pdf descargar resumen seis sombreros para pensar pdf complete catalog 2011 12 pdf the 30 days diabetes cure free pdf .torrent estres oxidativo en hortalizas pdf centro de convenciones puerto rico pdf free pdf of one naughty night by laurel mckee calidad de la informacion en internet criterios pdf the biggest loser dessert cookbook pdf a s 24 2012 pdf torrent microbiology pdf by tortora la voce del violino pdf the avengers comics pdf download the art of hand shadows albert pdf agatha christie ten little nigers pdf pdf a un o que despeda a o jugo finale hush hush 4 pdf martini el pan para un pueblo pdf download the curse of the gloamglozer pdf free word smart 4th edition smart guides pdf familia argeneau 7 the accidental vampire pdf pdf paediatric clinical cases uncovered free download pdf file jewel in the crown paul scott management control systems 12th edition pdf miller s anesthesia 7th edition pdf crochet dress patterns pdf vastu shastra pdf books free download the lover s dictionary mediafire pdf download the matrix revealed pdf download cubase studio 5 manual pdf ebook como preparar o nascimento do seu blog pdf wargods of aegyptus rulebook pdf ovis pdf recover mac ungido para los negocios edgardo silvoso pdf solution manual loss models from data to decisions pdf delhi master plan 2021 free download pdf how to build an hobby choppy helicopter pdf his dark materials books pdf morte e desenvolvimento humano pdf cours office 2003 en pdf no choice but seduction johanna lindsey pdf free download 4v thema 2 voortplanting en ontiwkkeling d toets pdf toyota corolla xl 92 1 3 pdf ucl notes on 1st order pdes pdf prieto s ez emilio algebra lineal empresa descargar pdf lycoming io 360 m1a operating manual pdf apostila custos da qualidade pdf opencart 1 4 template design cookbook pdf step by step linux guide pdf garry kasparov chess games pdf ley de transito terrestre venezuela 2011 pdf ipad2 back cover template pdf pdf el caso de lorenzo eram os deuses astronautas download pdf key pdf to go blackberry os6 gestion de la maintenance esa pdf buku anatomi fisiologi manusia untuk paramedis pdf international macroeconomics and finance nelson pdf essential elements 2000 violin pdf download pdf free download intellectual adventure of ancient man dieta da princesa kate pdf lisa kleypas mine till midnight pdf download berg e sehra by mohsin naqvi pdf microsoft excel tamil guides pdf format pdf ingenieria de transito y carreteras witch in the house jenna mcknight pdf free foundation series books pdf system administration for oracle e business suite pdf o pensamento complexo de edgar morin pdf c in depth pdf .torrent the science of victory pdf tangled up in you pdf 03 livro teoria de sistemas pdf nora roberts dance of dreams pdf download evermore by alyson noel pdf the limitation act pdf free download normas abnt no word pdf itil 2011 pdf library chemical biochemical and engineering thermodynamics 4th pdf verb tense 6th grade pdf preparacion para la exaltacion pdf iso 17666 2003 en pdf el nombre que ahora digo pdf future perfect tense exercises pdf ebooks free download pdf on pyramid energy livro os desastres de sofia pdf para baixar dress for success john t. molloy pdf john nunn s chess puzzle book pdf download kelas xi sma ipa matematika nugroho soedyarto pdf the devil and miss prym pdf download free itil service design 2011 edition pdf gas turbine world handbook pdf 2012 alcons view on line array pdf practical electronics for inventors pdf life fitness ct8500 cross trainer general assembly pdf esf cuaderno de ejercicios pdf baixar eletronica analogica e digital pdf el misterio de marie roget pdf jpm best pdf compressor v7 4 full coaching con pnl pdf descargar paul tippens fisica conceptos y aplicaciones 6ta edicion pdf fundamentals of corporate finance 8th edition pdf download new vehicle pdi checklist pdf sue tompkins aspects in astrology pdf konsep dan landasan teknologi pembelajaran pdf la isla de nim pdf free